2 of 12
Zach Gilford, The Mob Doctor
Previous Greatness: He broke our hearts as Matt Saracen on Friday Night Lights.
Clear eyes, full hearts, can lose. The former Dillon Panthers' quarterback was once part of a strong team, but now Gilford is on his own — especially considering his character is naively in the dark about his girlfriend Grace's deal with the mafia. The actor still brings his A-game as a cocky surgeon, but even Gilford's charm can't save the show from its absurd story lines (or that ridiculous title).