Beck can't shake the feeling that there's more to the story of Joe's lost former love, Candace. Determined to find out the truth, it's Beck's turn to go to shocking lengths to dig up the truth on Joe. But she might have gone too far.
Joe and Beck's lives have taken very different turns. On paper, each is doing great. But when a chance encounter brings every possibility to the surface, they each must decide which way they want their story to go.
Beck suffers a loss and Joe is right there with a shoulder to lean on. But he can't quite shake the worry and jealousy he still feels and he goes to creative lengths to explore his fears, even creating a fake identity so that he can give Beck's suspiciously handsome therapist a thorough checking-out. But Joe's luck is in danger of running out as Beck starts to suspect she's being followed.
Joe's fight for Beck's heart takes him out of the city. An accident injures him along the way, but Joe's not going to let a little thing like a head injury stand between him and true love. His devotion to Beck take him to a lavish but eerily remote summer home and a face-to-face with a worthy, equally-obsessed adversary who is just as intent on possessing her heart.
Joe and Beck's fledgling relationship is tested by Beck friend Peach's intrusive meddling. Joe does everything in his power to solve his Peach problem without making a mess, but Peach isn't making it easy.
Beck heads out of town to rendezvous with "The Captain," the man she's been texting; Joe follows and is shocked by what he finds; Beck realizes she and Joe are going to have to bring a scary level of truth and authenticity to their connection.
Beck seems uncertain that Joe is the right one, so he sets out to prove he's boyfriend material. But balancing this important time in their potential relationship with the tricky behind-the-scenes maneuvers is challenging for Joe.
Joe meets Beck, falls in love and goes down a social media rabbit hole to learn everything about her. He becomes so obsessed that he tracks her IRL (and they meet again). This might be a real shot at real love. But there are some things standing in the way... like her ex, Benji.