Two couples---with dramatically different parenting styles---raise their kids in L.A. Neurotic first-time parents Greg and Kim fuss over their infant's every twitch, while Kim's laid-back sister Christine and her husband, Jimmy, don't particularly mind their kids becoming TV zombies.
Greg and Jimmy plan a romantic anniversary surprise for the girls that includes dinner at an upscale restaurant, a Rascal Flatts concert and a chauffeur-driven limo. Unfortunately, things don't go quite as planned. Gary LeVox, Jay DeMarcus and Joe Don Rooney of Rascal Flatts appear as themselves.
Kim and Christine are unusually attentive to Greg and Jimmy after spending an evening listening to a critical husband constantly belittle his wife. The girls don't want to spend any more time with the couple, but Greg and Jimmy encourage the relationship in hopes that their good fortune with their wives will continue. Howie: Jeff Garlin. Joanne: Deborah Theaker.
Kim and Christine both want to have another baby after visiting a friend with a newborn, but Greg and Jimmy are against the idea, and refuse to make love with their wives until the women change their mind. Jen: Susan Moore.
Greg makes an attempt to get to know his neighbors better after he realizes that he and Kim aren't being invited to neighborhood parties because of his antisocial behavior. Richie: Joseph Limbaugh. Frank: Richard Speight Jr. Fran: Virginia Hamilton.
Dominic goes on his first date, and Christine and Jimmy give him completely opposite advice on how to act. Meanwhile, Greg gets jealous when he reads old personal letters from some of Kim's former boyfriends. Sawyer: Thea Rose. Jenny: Moriah Stapf.