Irked by Tick's enthusiasm, Liberty baits him into fighting an archvillain (Armin Shimerman), who happens to be bedridden and 112 years old. Stripper: Lisa Arturo. Arthur: David Burke. Liberty: Liz Vassey. Batmanuel: Nestor Carbonell.
Arthur's mom and sister hire a deprogrammer (Dave Foley) after he tells them of his choice to be a superhero and his partnership with Tick. Dot: Lisa Fredrickson. Bea: Beth Howland. Rex: Scott Schwartz. Mohammed: Jeff Sanders. Arthur: David Burke. Tick: Patrick Warburton.
Tick is jailed for contempt after testifying against a supervillain, who counsels his guard Captain Liberty on her love life. Destroyo: Kurt Fuller. DA: Molly Hagen. Judge: David Huddleston. Cell Mate: Robert Clendenin. Stanistoff: Victor Raider-Wexler. Liberty: Liz Vassey. Batmanuel: Nestor Carbonell.
The all-male League of Superheroes invites Tick and Arthur to join, prompting Captain Liberty to sue for discrimination. Champion: Jonathan Penner. Sonic Boom: Robert K. Mailhouse. Captain Comet: Jack Armstrong. Captain Liberty: Liz Vassey. Batmanuel: Nestor Carbonell.
The Tick assumes he's invited along when Arthur has a date with the girl he worshipped in high school; old nude photos haunt Captain Liberty, who faces a disciplinary hearing. Stacey: Missy Pyle. General: John Dennis Johnston. Arthur: David Burke. Liberty: Liz Vassey. Batmanuel: Nestor Carbonell.
Tick's inability to account for his past prompts a search for his identity; Captain Liberty dates a man who thinks she's a civilian. Mrs. Glick: Kari Coleman. Man: Larry Poindexter. Arthur: David Burke. Batmanuel: Nestor Carbonell.
A crimefighting duo's teamwork impresses the Tick, but Arthur detects an underlying tension between the pair. Fiery Blaze: Ron Perlman. Friendly Fire: Patrick Breen. Randolph: Matt Champagne. Kid Caboose: Michael Cornacchia. Johnny Republic: Antwon Tanner. Captain Liberty: Liz Vassey.
A superhero dies on a book tour while in the, um, care of Captain Liberty, who initiates a coverup, with Batmanuel playing impostor, while Arthur and the Tick deal with the body. Immortal: Sam McMurray. Clarissa: Meadow Sisto. General: Richard Penn. Batmanuel: Nestor Carbonell. Liberty: Liz Vassey.
In the series pilot, the Tick moves to the City and meets superhero wannabe Arthur, who helps battle an archival Soviet robot programmed to kill Jimmy Carter. Fishladder: Christopher Lloyd. Jimmy Carter: Brad Maynard. Bartender: Lisa Lu. The Cape: William Newman. Station Manager: E.J. Callahan. Arthur: David Burke.