With Web under investigation, an agent with a grudge against him leads the team after a ritualistic serial killer whose MO includes a stun gun and removal of victims' fingernails. Terry: Tom Wright. Stern: J.E. Freeman. Holly: Heather McComb. Brian: Joel David Moore. Web: Peter Coyote. Paul: Jay Harrington. Rebecca: Rachel Nichols.
An apparent copycat crime and a recanting witness cast doubt on the conviction won in Paul's first big case, a killer who literally stole his victims' hearts. Pope: Casey Siemaszko. Zoya: Michelle Forbes. Karen: Fay Masterson. Liz Fisher: Kelly Wolf. Laird: Ned Vaughn. Terry: Tom Wright. Alvarez: Marisol Ramirez. Judge: Jon Cedar. Paul: Jay Harrington. Web: Peter Coyote. Danny: Adam Baldwin.
Murders made to look like suicides have Rebecca going undercover to meet a suicide hot-line counselor who likes to work in person. Gary: Gabriel Olds. Traci: Jenette Goldstein. Amos: Joel Bissonnette. Charlotte: Shay Astar. Tanya: Toni Wynne. Amy: Elisa Leonetti. Rebecca: Rachel Nichols. Paul: Jay Harrington. Mel: Katie Finneran.
Circumstantial evidence backs up a claim against the prime suspect in a little boy's murder, but Rebecca thinks a witness is lying. Bunch: Zeljko Ivanek. Madison: Jennette McCurdy. Ellen: Anne Dudek. Tessa: Julie Claire. Nora: Emma Nicolas. St. Clair: Matthew Kaminsky. Price: Tommy Hinkley. Olsen: Kevin R. Kelly. Rebecca: Rachel Nichols. Paul: Jay Harrington. Danny: Adam Baldwin.
Innocent men who were planning, but had yet to carry out, multiple murders are being killed by someone who also knows details of Rebecca's past. Comack: Brian McNamara. Havens: Michael Zelniker. Manning: Michael Emerson. Kedlly Comack: Carrie Preston. Aubrey: Stephanie Patton. Rebecca: Rachel Nichols. Paul: Jay Harrington. Web: Peter Coyote.
Three rape-strangulation victims---one a Federal prosecutor---are linked to an S&M club, from which a member was recently banned. Brandt: Hart Bochner. Paige: Allison Dunbar. Strong: Michael Bowen. Skoll: Kristoffer Winters. Mrs. Strong: Shannon Hile. Rebecca: Rachel Nichols. Danny: Adam Baldwin. Web: Peter Coyote.
In the series pilot, Web has particular reasons for bringing in a rookie agent to replace the one taken out by a serial killer she was profiling. Web: Peter Coyote. Rebecca: Rachel Nichols. Paul: Jay Harrington. Danny: Adam Baldwin. Melody: Katie Finneran. Simon: Brett Rickaby. Carter: Nelsan Ellis.