Aaron Marcellus Aaron Marcellus

Just like the good ol' days, American Idol led Fox to a Tuesday night win — but not with its old audience.

With its first live show of the season, Idol pulled in 15.8 million viewers and a 5.0 in the adults 18-to-49 demo to help Fox notch the highest Tuesday demo rating of any network all season. The two-hour episode, however, lost in terms of viewership to CBS' NCIS-NCIS: Los Angeles combo, which averaged about a million more viewers.

Idol recap: Who got a second chance?

Against Idol

, NCIS (18 million, 3.4) hit a season low in the demo, but NCIS: LA (15.7 million) rose a bit to a 3.1. ABC was far more affected by Idol: Last Man Standing (7.4 million, 2.1), Cougar Town (4.3 million, 1.5) and The River (4.1 million, 1.5) all slumped to all-time rating lows.On NBC, Parenthood closed out its third season with 5.1 million and a 1.9 (up 4 and 12 percent) to tie Unforgettable in the demo.8 p.m.
NCIS 18 million viewers (3.4 demo rating)ABC: Last Man Standing 7.4 million (2.1); Cougar Town 4.3 million (1.5)Fox: American Idol 15.8 million (5.0) [8-10 p.m.]NBC: The Biggest Loser 5.7 million (2.0) [8-10 p.m.]CW: Hart of Dixie (R) .89 million (0.3)9 p.m.
NCIS: Los Angeles 15.7 million (3.1)ABC: The River 4.1 million (1.5) CW: Ringer 1.1 million (0.4)10 p.m.
Unforgettable 9.9 million (1.9)ABC: Body of Proof 6.7 million (1.3)NBC: Parenthood 5.1 million (1.9)