When the actresses attended the AFI Awards luncheon in January, Chaikin didn't even try to keep her cool when she saw one of her favorite actors. "Steve Carell was there and I was just a nerded-out fan girl and was like, 'Can I take a picture with you,'" recalls Chaikin.
"It was a hunt," Doubleday clarifies. "I was on the right side of the building, she was on the left. We were coordinating [tracking him down]."
While Chaikin eventually got her picture with Carell, Doubleday admits The Office actor seemed "a little bit freaked out" by their selfie stalking - not that Doubleday is one to judge. See who makes Doubleday, Rami Malek and Christian Slater starstruck in the video above!