Damien Fahey Damien Fahey

Lou Diamond Phillips took his seat on the I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here! throne earlier this week, but the show's hosts are already looking for his successor.

"I would love to see Clay Aiken, maybe Lance Bass and Paris Hilton on [next season]. Boy George too," Damien Fahey tells TVGuide.com. "Lindsay Lohan would be great. I think you need someone huge, like a Tom Cruise or something. Imagine that."

Relive all the jungle action with our I'm a Celebrity gallery

Fahey's co-host, Myleene Klass

, is imagining Cruise's Jerry Maguire co-star though. While her pie-in-the-sky pick would be Angelina Jolie, Klass thinks Cuba Gooding Jr. "could do really well" on the NBC survival-of-the-fittest series. "He looks like he could handle the jungle," she says.But we may be getting ahead of ourselves here. Fahey says he doesn't have "100 percent confirmation" on a second season, but Klass, who made mention of it on the finale, says she's gotten word of one. "That's what I've been told," she says. "I certainly hope so since they told me to say that."

Test your knowledge of reality competition shows

Despite apparently being out of the renewal loop, Fahey says he foresees another jungle adventure come June 2010 thanks to the "huge buzz" Season 1 had, courtesy of Speidi and, well, mostly Speidi. "It's probably the most talked-about show that's been on in years," he says. "If I was a betting man, I would say we would see a Season 2. I would love to come back."