Zach Cregger and Jamie-Lynn Sigler Zach Cregger and Jamie-Lynn Sigler

Dating your friend's ex can be awkward — especially if they don't even remember you!

Fall TV popularity contest: Will you make another playdate with Guys with Kids?

In this exclusive first look of Guys with Kids

' Sept. 26 episode, Nick prepares the gang to meet Chris' new date (guest star Eva Amurri Martino), who happens to be his ex. Unfortunately, the reunion doesn't quite go as planned.Watch the sneak peek below. Guys with Kids airs Wednesdays at 8:30/7:30c.