If Clay Aiken seemed a little too pulled together Wednesday night after learning he had lost the American Idol crown to Ruben Studdard, it may be because he already knew the outcome! Idol judge Simon Cowell told Fox's Good Day Live Thursday that Aiken peeked over host Ryan Seacrest's shoulder and saw Studdard's name on the card "about five minutes before he was due to go out [on stage]." Aiken, however, insisted to Extra that he was "completely in the dark" about who won. Meanwhile, Nielsen estimates that an average 33.7 million viewers watched the two-hour climax, giving Fox its best Wednesday ratings in history.