Premieres: Monday, Jan. 3 at 8/7c on ABC
Where We Left Off: Jake Pavelka proposed to Vienna Girardi on March 1. They broke up by June.
What's Next: We had ranked Season 11's Brad Womack as the smartest of all Bachelors. Why? Because when he didn't find love on reality TV, he did the most sensible thing ever done on the The Bachelor: He refused to choose a winner. We cheered his good judgment from the couch! But no more. More than three years later, Brad has decided to try his luck on the show again.