X

Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

TVGuidecom readers rank the remaining wannabes

Shaun Harrison
AIRanking-TopFive-SyeshaMercado5.JPG
1 of 10 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-SyeshaMercado5

No. 5) Syesha Mercado landed in the last spot once again with only 3.8 percent of the vote. We'd like to know her super-secret power source that kept her on the show longer than Carly!
2 of 10 Ray Mickshaw/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-SyeshaMercado10

TVGuide.com readers rate Syesha: "I'm happy to see Syesha in for another week. Maybe after this good performance she will be able to express herself better." (Darcey) "Poor Syesha. Hoping her personality doesn't go back in hiding." (Rushmore)
3 of 10 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-BrookeWhite1

No. 4) Brooke White got a bit of a bump from Carly's voters and rose to 6.7 percent in our Power Rankings. Now if she can just get through a song without stopping....
4 of 10 Ray Mickshaw/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-BrookeWhite6

TVGuide.com readers rate Brooke: "She's having a nuclear meltdown and what's with that stupid pouting and biting her lips" (mspisces) "Brooke had several extremely memorable and moving performances early on that built up her stock." (MahlerFan)
5 of 10 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-JasonCastro4

No. 3) Jason Castro is still hanging on after his disastrous performance of "Memory." He comes in at third place with 12.7 percent of the vote.
6 of 10 Ray Mickshaw/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-JasonCastro9

TVGuide.com readers rate Jason: "There is no explanation for Jason continuing." (jtoo) "I love Jason. He has a great style and many people find it appealing." (Dixiebelle31)
7 of 10 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-DavidArchuleta2

No. 2) Archie wowed Randy and Paula with his version of "Think of Me," but he still saw his biggest dip in our Power Rankings in over a month. He only garnered 20.9 percent of the vote.
8 of 10 Ray Mickshaw/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-DavidArchuleta7

TVGuide.com readers rate David A.: "His choices are seriously nauseating, made even more painful by his lack of depth." (Tmsassan) "I vote for David A. because I like him, and for no other reason." (angelcrossing)
9 of 10 Frank Micelotta/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-DavidCook3

No. 1) David Cook is at the top of our Power Rankings once again with a huge lead: 55.8 percent! Is there any stopping this standout from taking the entire competition
10 of 10 Ray Mickshaw/Fox

AIRanking-TopFive-DavidCook8

TVGuide.com readers rate David C.: "David Cook, who I originally thought was obnoxious, is growing on me." (Carlaria) "I'm sorry, Randy, but David C. is the one to beat, not David A." (catmom)