Join or Sign In

Sign in to customize your TV listings

Continue with Facebook Continue with email

By joining TV Guide, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

TVGuidecom readers rate the remaining wannabes

1 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox


No. 6) Poor Syesha Mercado is in last place for the sixth straight week in our power rankings! She just can't catch a break with the judges or America. This week, she garnered only 1.1 percent of the vote.
2 of 12 Fox

TVGuide.com readers rate Syesha:

"I think she can outshine any of the guys." (zazu310) "How in the world is Syesha still on this show The girl can sing, but has she ever come in higher than next-to-last on the TV Guide polls" (kaysidawn)
3 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox


No. 5) Brooke White did the best she could on Mariah Carey night, singing a low-key version of "Hero," but still ended up second-to-last in our Power Rankings with a lowly 4.9 percent.
4 of 12 Fox

TVGuide.com readers rate Brooke:

"There is no doubt she will have a great career ahead." (akfreak) "Brooke is  not unique, just ordinary, and not as adorable as she thinks she is." (trombone)
5 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox


No. 4) Carly Smithson belted out a powerful version of "Without You," but the judges weren't in love with it. Give her a break, guys (Simon)! But since America listens to Simon, Carly only scored 5.9 percent in our Power Rankings.
6 of 12 Fox

TVGuide.com readers rate Carly:

"Every week she keeps taking risks and nailing them!" (alxsavage) "While Syesha is generic, Carly is way overdone." (JaySix)
7 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox


No. 3) Jason Castro has a decent female fan following but only scored 9.9 percent of the vote this week. He'd make the top three if it were up to us, but will America agree
8 of 12 Michael Becker/Fox

TVGuide.com readers rate Jason:

"Jason has a pretty voice but no people skills, and... ya gotta know how to work the public." (mctyeire1) "There is no way I would ever pay to see Jason at a concert." (lucyw)
9 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox


No. 2) David Archuleta wowed the judges with his version of "If You Believe" and his leather pants wowed millions of tweens, but David is still a distant second place to David Cook at 24.4 percent.
10 of 12 Michael Becker/Fox

TVGuide.com readers rate David A.:

"He has great talent for his age and will go far, so I don't worry if he wins or loses." (kimberlyanne89) "He seems like a nice enough kid, but he's kind of boring." (MrsT1040)
11 of 12 Frank Micelotta/Fox


No. 1) David Cook took another risk this week and sang a dark, alternative version of "Always Be My Baby," and the risk paid off. He snagged the top spot once again in our rankings with a whopping 54.6 percent of the vote.
12 of 12 Michael Becker/Fox

TVGuide.com readers rate David C.:

"My favorite contestant of all time. Every performance gives me goosebumps." (gapeach688) "I didn't think he was all that great [last week]. I'm sure it inflated his ego even more." (lonewriter)