Season 1, Episode 6 The Time the Truth Was Told

First Aired: November 29, 1999

Sarah learns a dark part of Maguire's past after the arrival of his former crony (Jeremy Renner); Romy presses the issue of J.B.'s lack of intimacy toward her. Joan: Faye Grant. Dean: Christian Mills. Claire: Elizabeth Bogush. Evan: Thomas Burr. Romy: Jennifer Garner. Maguire: Johnathon Schaech. J.B.: Diego Serrano. Sarah: Jennifer Love Hewitt.