Season 1, Episode 5 The Time They All Came Over for Thanksgiving

First Aired: November 22, 1999

After a snag in her recording plans, Sarah finds herself hosting Thanksgiving for a quirky quartet of Maguire; aspiring suitors Spencer and Tony; and a former opera conductor (John Billingsley). Tony: Rino Romano. Spencer: Patrick Fabian. Maguire: Johnathon Schaech. Romy: Jennifer Garner. Sarah: Jennifer Love Hewitt.