In the Season 2 premiere, a new church policy dictates that Boyce have a physical examination, and he's sure he's in terrific shape—until the results of one test say otherwise. Meanwhile, Lolli's sister moves to town.
A lesbian couple want to wed in Boyce's church, which creates a rift between him and the elders, but also causes him to examine his relationship with Lolli when he sees the couple have familiar problems.
In the Season 2 finale, Boyce returns to the studio to record a new song, but it also means that old habits are hard to break. Meanwhile, Lolli and Barton tend to church matters in Boyce's absence; and Stamps and Kim are unsure about going public with their relationship.