Supernatural's biggest stars are apparently too famous to remember Richard Speight Jr and Rob Benedict.
The mothers-in-law pose as single women in search of beaus. Logan: Paul Lynde. Eve: Eve Arden. Kaye: Kaye Ballard. Herb: Herbert Rudley. Roger: Richard Deacon. Jerry: Jerry Fogel. Suzie: Deborah Walley.
Show More »
Download the TV Guide app for iPhone, iPad and Android!