Riley desperately searches for the client list and her efforts put everyone at risk, including Georgia, Nikki and Judge Overton. Riley also tells Lacey the reason why she was attacked, which then puts a strain on their friendship. Meanwhile, Selena and Derek face a difficult decision that could put their jobs in jeopardy when a French couple show up at the spa.
Riley discovers that the client list has been stolen; Evan gets a step closer to uncovering Riley's hidden life; Dale and Lacey receive news that could accelerate their plans to have a family of their own; Derek asks Selena to make a commitment to their relationship.
Riley volunteers at a charity golf tournament and learns that a judge is spearheading a task force that could put her and the Rub in serious jeopardy. Later, Travis tricks Kyle into hosting a sleepover; and Riley and Derek get an unwelcome surprise when they respond to an alarm at the spa.
Riley becomes consumed with wedding plans for Georgia and Harold's big day; Kyle tries to relieve some of Riley's financial burden; Evan and Trimble go undercover in a massage parlor as part of a prostitution investigation; Shelby and Evan face challenges in their relationship; Dale plans a bold maneuver for Lacey.
Riley convinces Lacey to attend their high-school reunion; Selena warns Derek about a client who wants to take their relationship outside of the spa; Linette struggles with rehab and leans on Kyle for support; Evan tries to focus on his relationship with Shelby.
Riley attends church to help deal with the struggles in her marriage and some difficult work decisions. Meanwhile, Kyle prepares to testify against his former employer; Selena warns Derek about an overzealous client; and Evan takes Shelby out on a date.
Riley falls into tempting new terrain when she connects with a wealthy single father. Elsewhere, Kyle fights with an inmate and loses visiting privileges; electricity goes out at the spa; and Georgia and Lacey throw a baby shower for Dale's disagreeable sister.
Riley rekindles her dream of becoming a singer when she learns that one of her client's knows a high-profile music agent. Meanwhile, Kyle experiences trouble with a fellow inmate that could jeopardize his defense; and Evan grows close to a female cadet at the police academy.
Riley learns that Linette wants Katie to enter a local pageant. Meanwhile, Selena and Derek experience an awkward encounter in a co-ed locker room; Evan offers to take Travis to visit Kyle in jail; and Lacey and Dale visit a fertility specialist.
Selena doesn't trust Riley's newest hire, who worked at a strip club; Derek keeps a secret that could jeopardize the Rub of Sugarland; Riley receives an unusual request from a pro football player who is a client and likes to test boundaries.
Linette is in a car accident and temporarily moves in with Riley while she recovers; Evan takes on a dangerous job in order to help Riley with a financial burden; Riley decides to make the Rub of Sugarland coed and hires a masseur.
Riley's secret life at the spa is threatened when two detectives mistakenly assume she has information that would aid their investigation of Kyle. Meanwhile, Georgia introduces Riley to the new man in her life; two new young women begin work at the spa; and Evan takes Riley on a date.
The second season begins with Riley and Kyle meeting at the Rub and being interrupted by a cop. Later, Riley inherits a judge as a new client; and she befriends the mother of one of Travis' classmates.