Riley balks at facing rumors about Kyle when Linette is made cochair of a social event. Meanwhile, a law student comes to the spa looking for extras, but Riley discovers a connection between him and one of her coworkers, putting the spa's secret in jeopardy.
Riley wonders if she is ready to start dating again after a massage mishap with an eligible client. Later, Riley intervenes in Linette's relationship with Garrett when ugly secrets from his past come to light.
One of Riley's coworkers elopes, and the event forces Riley to think about the imperfections in her marriage. Meanwhile, Lacey reveals that she's been hiding a secret from Riley; Evan sees a new girl; and Riley helps an insecure client learn basic dating techniques.
Selena and Evan start dating, which leads to tension between Selena and Riley. Meanwhile, Travis is caught in a "curious situation" with Taylor's daughter; and Linette applies for a loan to buy the salon.
Riley gives romance a try and goes on a date with a doctor, but her past comes back to haunt her. Meanwhile, Dee Ann gets involved with a high-powered client; and Linette and Lacey have their face day with Taylor at the salon.
The first season concludes with Riley's husband returning home. Meanwhile, Riley is put in charge of the spa after Georgia learns that the authorities may be on to her, but the new responsibilities threaten to expose Riley's secret life.