So You Think You Can... Episodes

2005, TV Show

So You Think You Can Dance Episode: "2 of 20 Voted Off"

Season 5, Episode 7
Episode Synopsis: In the first results show of the season, two of the Top 20 dancers are eliminated. Also: Rapper Sean Kingston performs "Fire Burning."
Original Air Date: Jun 11, 2009
Guest Cast Sean Kingston

So You Think You Can Dance Episode Recap: Week One Results Season 5, Episode 7

And then there were 18. It's sad to see amazingly talented dancers leave the competition but it's inevitable as we count down to America's Favorite Dancer. Did you agree with the judge's decisions or were you shocked with who they sent home?

First, let me spare a little bit of time for the fabulous Cat. I love her dress tonight. She looks cute, and her manner with the dancers is so comforting — when she's not forced to be dramatic to ratchet up the tension.

This week we had our first group dance, and I was pretty impressed. I'm very happy Shane Sparks is back in the mix. I like that they spotlighted Phillip, Tony, and Caitlin. There were some really hard-hitting, interesting moves. I liked the different levels and the different speeds. Nicely done.

Before the results, we did a bit of catching up with the Top 20. We learn some rules: Respect boundaries; communication is essential; it's important to feel comfortable; shared hobbies help; and it takes hard work and perspiration.

No more delays. Who are the bottom three couples?

Max and Kayla: Safe. They were so hot. It would have been a crime if people didn't recognize.

Randi and Evan: Safe. And they'd better be. I loved their piece.

Phillip and Jeanine: Safe. I was much more taken with him (but it was his style). I do like this pairing.

Caitlin and Jason: Safe. Even though I wasn't feeling Caitlin last night, I'm very happy they're safe. I love Jason.

Melissa and Ade: Safe. Their piece was really amazing. I'm so glad voters agreed.

Ashley and Kupono: I'm so glad people got this piece. I wasn't worried, but you never know. It was strange and awesome. Kupono checked it off his list.

Tony and Paris: Dancing for their lives. I'm not surprised. They were serviceable last night. More than serviceable, in fact. But I wanted them to be amazing — especially Tony. They let us down last night.

Judges reaction: Adam isn't surprised by these results. There was a lot of Twitter love for them, but he thinks it was because they're charming not because of their dancing. He encourages them to bring it with their solos.

Asuka and Vitolio: Dancing for their lives. I'm not surprised. I just didn't love their genre, and I wanted them to bring some serious personality to it.

Judges reaction: Mary is not shocked. She urges them to dance like they've never danced before.

Brandon and Janette: Safe. I didn't really think ballroom would knock them out of the competition so I'm happy with these results.

Jonathan and Karla: Dancing for their lives. I'm not terribly shocked. I did have some trouble with Jonathan last night, and it looks like he brought his partner down with him.

Something new they're trying this season that I can do nothing but support is to feature a different style of dance from around the world each week. Tonight we get a taste of the tango, and it is served hot piping hot. Merriam LeRici and Leonardo Barrio Nuevo were amazing. In general, I'm a fan of the tango, and they did not disappoint me. I'm not sure I can get enough of these two incredible, sexy dancers. I didn't want to take my eyes away for even one second! I was watching with a friend, and she made me watch it again. Perhaps "made me watch it again" is too strong. I was more than willing to watch that performance again. I saw some very impressive and intricate footwork. Amazing focus between them. Nice lifts, wonderful emotion. Their concentration and connection is wonderful. I could watch dancing like this for hours. Very nice finish. They were amazing throughout. What a treat to watch.

Dancing for their lives

Paris: Her contemporary piece had great technique going for it. I'm not sure I'm connecting emotionally with her, though. I did like what I saw. We'll see if it's enough.

Tony: I've seen more personality and technique from him before. I just wasn't feeling it. Was it just me, or did he kind of seem to be flailing around the stage? I thought we'd really see something special here.

Asuka: Ballroom solos are always hard, but she brought some sexy back and great high energy and personality. I enjoyed it. Great footwork. And I loved her little flouncy skirt. I'm not sure I loved that sexy face she was putting on at the end, but I do enjoy her.

Vitolio: His jumping splits are always impressive. Very emotional. I was right there with him. It probably didn't hurt that he wasn't wearing a shirt. Very powerful. I'm into it.

Karla: Nice control. Very nice technique.

Jonathan: Very acrobatic, which I didn't love. I think it helped him to showcase his physical strength but I wasn't feeling it.

Featured musical performance of the week: Sean Kingston. Those of you who know me know I don't usually talk about anything non-dance related having to do with this show. However, I'm always interested to see if dancers are featured in the musical performances, and I love when they are. So enjoyed what I saw. That's all I'll say.

So, who's going home? Can you even stand the suspense? If I had to choose I wouldn't mind seeing Paris and Jonathan go home.

Girls: The judges are unanimous.

Karla: Very good. Her solo was strong, but she needs to be careful that is isn't just a series of steps. Nigel tells her to bring your own personality. She did enough to remain in the competition. (Nigel is also quick to point out that this decision isn't just based on what the judges saw tonight or last night. They always try to cast the show so they represent all the different genres.)

Asuka: All she has going for her is ballroom and the jive. She's a little star when she's performing.

Paris: She didn't bring everything she could bring. Looking at the other contemporary dancers, she'll be leaving.

Boys: The judges are again unanimous. They didn't think any one of the three danced particularly well this evening. They didn't think what they saw from any one of them was good enough to stay in the competition for very long.

Vitolio: The judges didn't see his personality in his routines, and they feel that something isn't clicking for him so far in the studio. They're not sure how he's going to regain it but he'd better learn how quickly because they keep him.

The judges are disappointed in both Tony and Jonathan. They were both in their genres — or close to them — but didn't do very well.

Tony: The judges were surprised he did locking, but he didn't do it very well.

Jonathan: He was a little better last night. His dancing wasn't great, but his gymnastics were. They decide to keep him.

I am so shocked Tony is being sent home. I thought he had enough charisma to make it at least a few more weeks, and I thought the judges wanted to see him develop a bit more. Was I impressed with his dancing tonight? Not at all. Did I want to see him stay over Jonathan? Yes. I guess that goes to show you that no one is safe (a lesson we learned bitterly with Natalie during Vegas week). I'm sad to see Paris go but of the three I think she was the weakest.

What did you think? Please weigh in below.

show less

And then there were 18. It's sad to see amazingly talented dancers leave the competition but it's inevitable as we count down to America's Favorite Dancer. Did you agree with the judge's decisions or were you shocked with who they sent home?

read more

Related Links

Other Links:
So You Think You Can Dance

Are You Watching?

Loading ...
Premiered: July 20, 2005, on FOX
Rating: TV-PG
User Rating: (1,499 ratings)
Add Your Rating: 1 stars2 stars3 stars4 stars5 stars
Premise: A national dance competition from the producers of `American Idol.'



So You Think You Can Dance (Major Competitive Reality Shows)
Buy So You Think You Can Dance (Major Competitive Reality Shows) from
From Mason Crest Publishers (Paperback)
Temporarily out of stock. Order now and we'll deliver when available. We'll e-mail you with an estimated delivery date as soon as we have more information. Your credit card will not be charged until we ship the item.
Buy New: $7.60 (as of 1:23 AM EST - more info)
So You Think You Can Dance Get Fit: Cardio Funk
Buy So You Think You Can Dance Get Fit: Cardio Funk from
From Paramount (DVD)
Usually ships in 24 hours
Buy New: $12.07 (as of 1:23 AM EST - more info)

More Products

TV GUIDE Users' Most Popular