The lives of three teens (Taylor; Olivia; Kolby) whose parents are pastors are chronicled. In the opener: Taylor reveals a fantasy; Olivia questions the paternity of her daughter; and Kolby asks her parents for permission to start dating.
Nikita and Victoria go on date for the first time in seven years, which leads Kolby to rethink her relationship with Micah. Meanwhile, Olivia discovers a secret about Frankie; and Taylor's dad suffers a health scare.
Olivia wants to take her daughter trick-or-treating on Halloween, but her parents are against it. Meanwhile, Kolby celebrates her first Halloween with a house party; and Taylor and Marie try to keep the church going while Ken is in the hospital.
Ken and Marie throw Taylor an 18th birthday party, but things get wild as the night goes on. Meanwhile, Victoria loosens the reins on Kolby dating; and Olivia worries that her partying past could have lasting effects on her daughter.