In an enhanced episode, Lindsay has an audition for a well-known casting director; Nancy gets ready for her prom; Haleigh's wedding day doesn't turn out like she planned; and Colleen continues her quest for romance.
Colleen gets set up on a date by her matchmaker again, but this time with a shorter man; Lindsay arranges a meeting with her father; Haleigh shops for a wedding dress; Nancy introduces her prom date to her family.
Colleen hires a matchmaker after too many disappointing dates with men she met online; Lindsay gets ready to see her father for the first time in 16 years; Nancy searches for a prom dress; Haleigh starts planning her wedding even though her dad disapproves.
Colleen tries online dating; Haleigh's boyfriend prepares to propose; Lindsay consults a private investigator to discuss the search for her father; Nancy wants to go to the prom, but must be asked by a senior to make it happen.
In an enhanced episode, high schooler Nancy shops for a prom dress; former wrestler Lindsay searches for her father, whom she hasn't seen since she was 11; Colleen moves to San Diego looking for love; and Haleigh wonders if her boyfriend is going to propose.