Kay breaks up with her tightly wound girlfriend, who then takes out her frustrations on Jake by wiping out his identity. Elsewhere, Gil tries to land a job at Jake's company, and Annie tangles with her merciless boss. The series finale.
Jake grows irritated at some of Annie's quirks, so he secretly enlists Kay to help modify her behavior. In return, Jake helps Kay organize a Valentine's Day celebration for her new girlfriend. Meanwhile, Gil and Dennah become smitten with firefighters.
Annie and Jake deface a sign with graffiti at their apartment building, creating a stir and causing a super mom's investigation. Elsewhere, Gil, Dennah and Kay compete for a "plus one" spot on a wedding guest list.
Jake and Annie clash when it appears one of them watched the season finale of their favorite show without the other. Dennah enlists her cop boyfriend (Rob Riggle) and his partner (Natasha Leggero) to administer a polygraph test to determine the culprit.
The gang tries to help Gil realize he's too dependent on Jake, but the resultant change in their relationship unbalances the group dynamic. Meanwhile, Kay has conflicting emotions about an old love interest.
Jake tries to connect with Annie's two fathers and ends up bonding with Kevin 1 over motorcycles, leading to family troubles. Meanwhile, Gil gears up for the annual Flemish Pride Parade and seeks Annie's help to stage a musical production.
An epic storm sweeps into Chicago, forcing the gang to seek shelter in the basement and marring Jake and Annie's first-date anniversary. As Gil impresses with his take-charge stance, Annie, Kay and Dennah obsess over what Jake may be hiding in his desk.
Annie and Jake set out to create a haunted house in their apartment for Halloween, but the trick's on them when a super-mom derails their plans. Elsewhere, Dennah hopes to impress at an exclusive party with her skimpy costume, and Gil and Kay spy on Gil's ex-wife.
A comedy that tracks the highs and woes of a longtime couple and their romantic obstacles. In the series premiere, Annie fumes about Jake's inability to commit just as he's about to propose. Ken Marino and Casey Wilson star.
Annie's old flame lies in a coma, so Annie visits him at the hospital with Jake. Before long, Jake's voice miraculously awakens him and the two become fast friends, to Annie's chagrin. Meanwhile, Kay pens a young-adult vampire novel, which Dennah and Gil then send to a publisher.
Annie at last meets her biological mother (Nia Vardalos), whose take-charge attitude wows Annie and Jake. Her presence soon stirs up tension for Annie's fathers, however. Meanwhile, Gil and Kay enter a cake competition.