Season 4, Episode 10 Duff's Birthday

First Aired: April 3, 2008

The Charm City staff surprises Duff with a meatball cake for his birthday. Also: an autograph-book cake is made.

Watch This

I. Marlene King and Troian Bellisario
Troian Bellisario recalls her wildest PLL fan encounters

The Pretty Little Liars star and creator recall their wildest -- and sometimes incredilbly uncomfortable -- encounters with fans