Andrew and Zelda try to pick out Christmas gifts for one another with help from their friends. Meanwhile, Big Bird faces a crisis when a customer signs up for a news interview about an unsuccessful matching experience.
Andrew discovers he's easily swayed by those around him, especially Stu and Zelda. Meanwhile, Andrew confronts Big Bird about a business strategy, but his efforts backfire; and Andrew seeks a new hobby.
Andrew and Zelda ditch their individual haunted holiday traditions to throw a joint Halloween bash, but their decision leaves their best friends Stu and Stephie feeling betrayed. Meanwhile, Big Bird looks for an opportunity to promote Wallflower; and Henry invites musician Ray Parker Jr. to a company party.
Andrew and Zelda research each other on the Internet and uncover awkward surprises. Meanwhile, Big Bird tries to discern what her coworkers really think of her; and Stu advises Stephie on finding the perfect date online.
Idealistic online matchmaker Andrew falls for no-nonsense lawyer Zelda in this romantic-comedy series. In the opener, the two meet for the first time when she comes into his online-dating workplace to deal with a misunderstanding. They immediately have chemistry, and he thinks he's seen her somewhere before.