Season 6, Episode 18
Matt and Sarah argue over their wedding plans and their agreement to forego buying an engagement ring. Mary and Lucy fly to Buffalo where Mary hopes to meet an ex-boyfriend, but their trip takes an unexpected turn after they reach their destination. Sarah: Sarah Danielle Madison. Ben: Geoff Stults. Matt: Barry Watson. Mary: Jessica Biel. Lucy: Beverley Mitchell.
Original Air Date: Apr 22, 2002
Sarah Danielle Madison: Sarah Glass
Geoff Stults: Ben Kinkirk