Season 5, Episode 18
The striking resemblance of Robbie's new friend, Marie, to Mary raises eyebrows among discerning Camdens. Annie's invitation for her to stay for dinner only makes things weirder. Back in Buffalo, unbeknownst to Robbie, Mary makes plans to meet her old boyfriend Wilson (Andrew Keegan) for the evening. And Matt meets Robbie's ex, Cheryl, at the restaurant where she works. Robbie: Adam LaVorgna. Matt: Barry Watson. Annie: Catherine Hicks.
Original Air Date: Apr 23, 2001
Andrew Keegan: Wilson