4 of 24
Why It Should Stay: Between all the NCISes and CSIes on CBS over the years, Minds, now in its eighth season, has a lower profile, but it still maintains a consistently strong viewership. It also launched a season-long villain arc this year for the first time to keep things fresh.
Why It Should Go: While there are plot twists galore, the episodes and cases are heavy on the gore/shock factor now and low on actual profiling. Garcia shouldn't be able to find everything on her wall of computers!