I'm wondering what you think ...

Question: I'm wondering what you think of Saving Grace. I'm from Oklahoma, so I'm trying to figure out if my disappointment with the show comes from how it stereotypically portrays Oklahomans. There are the cowboy and Indian detectives. The angel chews tobacco. Part of the first episode took place at the stockyards, with the redneck millionaire cattleman hitting on Grace. The only character who doesn't seem like a walking stereotype is Grace herself, and she just seems off. A detective in Oklahoma driving a Porsche, even a beat-up one? On what planet? How much do they think detectives earn? And she's Catholic? Not that there aren't Catholics in Oklahoma, but there aren't that many, not like there are Baptists and Methodists. Why stereotype every character but one? Do you think future episodes are going to get any better? For me, the only thing this show accomplishes is to remind me how much I miss Joan of Arcadia. I'm still mad at CBS for that one.
Answer: I've seen the second episode, and that may be all I'll bother with (unless the numbers hold up and it becomes the kind of megahit I can't afford to ignore completely). In my review, I described it as "frantically offbeat" and "self-consciously edgy while flirting with cosmic schmaltz." I was riveted and entertained by Holly Hunter but found the premise puzzling and overdone — an R-rated FX-style Touched by an Angel? Doesn't really work for me. I can't comment on the Oklahoma stereotypes, except to say that they did make some pretty obvious choices. I found Grace to be awfully heavy-handed in most regards — lacking in, I guess you'd say, grace.

Editor's Picks

10:01PM NBC

Streaming

Find a TV Show

See more »

Advertisement
130521photo-Gary-Sinise1

Shows We Lost This Season

Say a final goodbye to CSI: NY and more of the series that won't be back on your TV next year

Our Partners

Shop

Buy Saving Grace: The Final Season from Amazon.com

From 20th Century Fox (DVD)
Usually ships in 24 hours
Buy New: $26.49 (as of 7:08 AM EST - more info)

Buy The Three Billy Goats Gruff / The Three Little Pigs, Told by Holly Hunter from Amazon.com

(Amazon Instant Video)
Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Buy New: $2.99 (as of 4:52 AM EST - more info)

Buy Saving Grace: Holly Hunter Live at the Paley Center from Amazon.com

(DVD)
Usually ships in 24 hours
Buy New: $14.99 (as of 4:52 AM EST - more info)