In 2002 John Doe opened with ...
In 2002 John Doe
opened with a naked man curled on his side in a clearing. It moved to a close-up of his eye as it opened and looked around. In 2003 Stargate SG-1
opened its seventh season with a naked man curled on his side in a clearing. It moved to a close-up of his eye as it opened and looked around. Now in 2006 we have Kyle XY
which opened with a naked man.... I know TV repeats itself, but this is a bit much. Were the same writers on all three shows? Or did everybody just like this scene so much we have to see it again and again?Answer:
Not being familiar with the Stargate
setup, I would just say the similarities between the John Doe
and Kyle XY
premises go beyond the naked-hunk-in-the-woods image, though it is a striking one. Even a classic one. Which is why it's fair game to try it again, because the fact is that this image works. Kyle
seems to be getting some mileage out of it. Producers often express surprise when confronted with a scene or a shot that copies something that came before, but in this case, I can't imagine Kyle
's creators being unaware of such an iconic shot as the one that also opened John Doe
. Think of it as an homage, not a rip-off. And enjoy the show. It's kind of cute.