Matt Bomer, Willie Garson Matt Bomer, Willie Garson

What better time to wig out than Halloween?!

On Thursday's new episode of White Collar (9/8c, USA), Mozzie (Willie Garson) must craft a new look for himself after he came face-to-face with Neal's new handler, Agent David Seigel (Warren Kole), last week at one of his not-exactly-legal businesses.

"As long as you're working with Suit the sequel, I have to become a new man," Mozzie tells Neal (Matt Bomer) as he tries on a wig closely resembling Ringo Starr's 'do — or is it more more Justin Bieber-esque?

TV wigs: Tricks or treats?

Fortunately, like any good criminal, Mozzie can multi-task and helps Neal brainstorm on his latest heist while also narrowing down choices for his new appearance. Watch this exclusive sneak peek to see Mozzie's new looks and weigh in on which you like the most below:

White Collar airs Thursdays at 9/8c on USA. Do you prefer Mozzie as a blonde or a brunette?