Chuy Valencia Chuy Valencia

Chuy Valencia won the first two elimination challenges on Top Chef, but he couldn't make it a three-peat. Instead, the Chicago-based chef got the boot after overcooking his salmon with goat cheese dish. "I knew I was screwed so I was expecting it," he tells TVGuide.com. "It's hard to forgive overcooking something." Find out when he realized it all had gone wrong and why he's happy he got eliminated.

Top Chef's Richie: I wasn't thinking clearly

Top Chef's Keith: I knew Sarah and Lindsay would throw me under the bus

Is bigger better? 5 things to know about Top Chef: Texas