On last night's Billy Joel-themed American Idol, Kimberley Locke stole the show with her classy rendition of "New York State of Mind." And I'd like to extend special props to Locke's stylist; for once, girlfriend looked as good as she sounded. Carmen Rasmusen, meanwhile, should probably start packing her bags. She took a perfectly good ballad — "And So It Goes" — and butchered it to within an inch of its life. (But she's so damn sweet, I voted for her anyway.) Who do you think should follow in Rickey Smith's footsteps and get the hook tonight? Click here to vote in today's Idol poll.