On Thursday night's Average Joe: The Joes Strike Back finale, 26-year-old Sin City model Anna Chudoba chose... (spoiler alert) ... Nathan, one of the made-over Joes. (Dude has got to ditch the mondo earrings, though.) This marks the first time in the franchise's history that the beauty has elected not to ride off into the sunset with an utterly vapid golden boy. Judging by the finale's epilogue, NBC considers its relationship with Average Joe ovah. Then again, maybe not: Season 2 contestant Alfred "Fredo" LaPonza (think ponytail) is heading up a $40 million lawsuit against NBC, claiming that the "makeover" twist, among other ideas, was conceived by him and two pals. NBC has been mum on the suit so far.