Adam Pally and Casey Wilson Adam Pally and Casey Wilson

Poor lonely Max.

Now that Penny (Casey Wilson) is dating Pete (Nick Zano) on Happy Endings, her BFF is feeling a little left out. What's a guy to do? Get a replacement Penny in the form of Nicole, er, Nickel!

Fall TV Report Card: How's the new class doing?

"A Nickel is worth five times as much as Penny," Max (Adam Pally

) tells Penny of his new pal, played by Kulap Vilaysack, in our exclusive sneak peek of Tuesday's episode.But will his plan to make Penny jealous work? And what's Nickel's own a-mah-zing word? Watch below to find out.

Happy Endings airs Tuesdays at 9/8c on ABC.