Jimmy Smits, Gail Simmons Jimmy Smits, Gail Simmons

NBC's new Jimmy Smits-fronted legal drama Outlaw and Bravo's Top Chef spinoff Just Desserts debuted Wednesday night, and we want to know what you thought of them — and what you think of every new show this season.

Vote: Which fall premieres won you over? Which flopped?

Do you rule in favor of Outlaw? Was Just Desserts sweet or sour?  Vote now! And if you like either show, don't forget to tell your friends and other fans to vote.Check back all fall to see what TVGuide.com users think of your favorite — and least favorite — new shows. And stay tuned to see the most liked and disliked of the new season.Also, be sure to mark your calendar (or use ours) to know when to vote for all the new shows.