Octavia Spencer, Debra Messing Octavia Spencer, Debra Messing

Are you joining Red Band Society? Will you book time for The Mysteries of Laura?

Now that both dramedies have premiered, we want to know if you think it's a hit or a miss — and what you think of every new show this season.

Meet the teens and docs of Fox's Red Band Society

Did you fall in love with Leo (Charlie Rowe) or any of the other kids from the hospital-set Fox show? Are you excited to see Laura (Debra Messing) juggle being a cop with being a mom?  Vote here now!

VIDEO: See why Debra Messing calls her Mysteries of Laura character a badass

Check back to see what TVGuide.com users pick as their favorite — and least favorite — new shows. And stay tuned to see the final rankings of the most liked and disliked freshman series.

Plus, check out our full calendar to help you keep track of all the premiere dates and when to vote.