Jerry O’Connell, Tony Shalhoub, Kal Penn, Chris Smith

Are you mad for We Are Men?

Now that CBS' bachelor comedy has premiered, we want to know if you think it's a hit or a miss — and what you think of every new show this fall season.

Vote: Which fall premieres are hits? Which are misses?

Do you want to bro it up with Carter (Chris Smith), Stuart (Jerry O'Connell), Gil (Kal Penn) and Frank (Tony Shalhoub)? Or is it a little too macho for your taste? Vote now! And don't forget to tell your friends and fellow TV fans to vote as well.

Check back to see what users think of your favorite — and least favorite — new shows. And stay tuned to see the final rankings of which freshman series readers love and hate.

Plus, check out our full calendar to help you keep track of all the premiere dates and when to vote.