Did Michael Weatherly's new show grab you by the horns, or are you ready to hop off? Did you love the twist in This Is Us, or did you totally see it coming? Let us know your thoughts by voting in our Fall TV Popularity Contest right here!
Check back to see what TVGuide.com users pick as their favorite — and least favorite — new shows. And stay tuned to see the final rankings of the most liked and disliked freshman series.
(Full disclosure: TVGuide.com is owned by CBS.)