Law & Order True Crime: The Menendez Murders made its killer debut on Tuesday night, going up against the season premiere of NCIS: New Orleans and a new episode of Ryan Murphy's American Horror Story: Cult.

Chronicles Erik and Lyle Menendez who stood on trial for the brutal murder of their parents, this eight-part limited series follows in the footsteps of Murphy's recent hit The People v. O.J. Simpson: American Crime Story. But did NBC's take on the mid-90's murder trial that captivated a nation live up to the hype? Is the dramatic retelling of Menendez brothers' crimes guilty of delivering must-see TV? Did Edie Falco arrest you with her fierce blonde wig? Let us know by voting in our Fall TV Popularity Contest!

Fall TV Popularity Contest: Which New Shows Won You Over?

Plus, check out our full calendar to help you keep track of all the premiere dates and when to vote, and our Fall TV Preview for scoop on all the new shows premiering this season.