Did Conviction make you forget all about Marvel's Agent Carter, or is the jury still out on the Hayley Atwell vehicle? Did time fly while you were watching Timeless, or did it have you checking your watch? Let us know your thoughts by voting in our Fall TV Popularity Contest right here!
Check back to see what TVGuide.com users pick as their favorite — and least favorite — new shows. Plus, check out our full calendar to help you keep track of all the premiere dates and when to vote, and our Fall TV Preview for scoop on all the new shows premiering this season.