Jake McDorman, Analeigh Tipton Jake McDorman, Analeigh Tipton

Will you make a date with Manhattan Love Story? Do you give Selfie a thumbs-up? Now that ABC's newest romantic comedies have debuted, we want to know: Did you fall in love?

Vote: Which fall premieres are hits? Which are misses?

Will you continue to root for Manhattan Love Story's Dana (Analeigh Tipton) and Peter (Jake McDorman)? Or was their inner monologue just too damn loud for your liking? Did Selfie's twist on My Fair Lady win you over? Or is the social media-obsessed Eliza (Karen Gillan) too vapid? Vote now! Check back to see which new fall shows TVGuide.com users have picked as their favorite — and least favorite.Plus: Check out our fall premiere calendar to keep track of all your favorite new shows.