The couple tied the knot in a small beach ceremony in Dana Point, Calif., and hosted the reception at a hotel balcony overlooking the ocean.
"Everything went off without a hitch," Pintauro said. "The wedding was terrific and everyone was so happy to be there. We had fun!"
Tabares, an entertainer at Las Vegas' Cosmopolitan hotel, proposed to the actor in April 2013 during a Palm Springs vacation. "I never thought I would ever get married," Tabares said. "I knew I would never marry a woman, and never thought I'd see the day that same-sex marriage would be legal, so it's definitely a life-long dream come true."
The couple's wedding ceremony streamed live and will replay again 9:30/8:30c Friday here.