Shawn Johnson, Derek Hough Shawn Johnson, Derek Hough

Reunited, and it feels so — oh, wait.

Dancing with the Stars All-Stars season features plenty of old faces, but only five original pairings — a consequence of casting multiple celebs who on their respective seasons shared the same pros.

But change can be a good thing, right? Seven (potentially eight) of the returning stars hope so. Below, we size up the season's new couples on a scale of 1 (worst) to 10 (best).

Dancing with the Stars All-Stars pairs revealed!

Dancing with the Stars All-Stars cast revealed! And there's a twist!