Rob and Kelley Rob and Kelley

Rob and Kelley got the boot on Sunday's Amazing Race, but the post-show hubbub isn't about their exit, but rather Natalie and Nadiya keeping James and Abba's money after finding it in a travel agency. "We couldn't believe that. We were shocked watching it," Kelley tells TVGuide.com. "We had no idea that happened. That was crazy." The monster truckers say they would've returned the money and — unlike the show — penalized not only the twins, but Trey and Lexi, with whom the girls split the money. How would they have punished them? Plus: Find out what you didn't see in Sunday's episode.

Amazing Race's Gary and Will: We're responsible for our own demise

Amazing Race's Caitlin and Brittany: We still don't understand how we got so lost

Amazing Race's Amy and Daniel: The stars weren't aligned for us