Gary Wojnar and Will Chiola Gary Wojnar and Will Chiola

After two close-call finishes, Gary and Will's Amazing Race luck ran out Sunday when they were eliminated after initially taking the wrong way to the Pit Stop. "We weren't close at all, but we knew we had to keep trying until Phil [Keoghan] told us we were eliminated," Will tells TVGuide.com. The self-professed super-fans of the Race are disappointed they didn't put up a better showing for fellow die-hards, but the substitute teachers say they are proud of one thing.

Amazing Race's Caitlin and Brittany: We still don't understand how we got so lost

Amazing Race's Amy and Daniel: The stars weren't aligned for us

Amazing Race's Rob and Sheila: We got screwed over