Cast

Michael Showalter Coop/Alan Shemper
Zak Orth J.J.
Ken Marino Victor
Liam Norton Arty
Gabriel Millman Caped Boy
Kevin Thomas Conroy Medieval Kid
Cassidy Ladden Mallrat Girl
Nina Hellman Nancy
Jacob Shoesmith Fox Moose
Whitney Vance Valerie
Benjamin Coppola Bobby
Jon Benjamin Can of Vegetables
Ian Helfer Bear Claw Coach
Jordan Maclean Alexa
Avi Setton Standup Comic
Kyle Gallner Bobby's Buddy
Kathleen Pandolfo Godspell Girl
Zachary Montgomery-Wicks Gail's Boy Camper
Danny Hopkins Raft Camper #1
Christopher Connors Raft Camper #2
Matt Carmeci Bunk Boy
Timothy Gasiewski Juke Box Kid #2
Angel Berlane Friends, Friends Girl #1
Christi Berlane Friends, Friends Girl #2
Bob Walz Drug Dealer
Joseph Kariuki Kenyan Runner
Joe Bryan Counselor
Christine Loebsack Counselor
Keith Oney Counselor