Cast

Danny DeVito Buddy Hall
Matthew Broderick Steve Finch
Kristin Davis Kelly Finch
Alia Shawkat Madison Finch
Jorge Garcia Wallace
Fred Armisen Gustave
Ryan Devlin Bob Murray
Sean O'Bryan Mayor Young
Brenda M. Crichlow News Reporter No. 1
Jill Krop Reporter No. 2
Nathaniel DeVeaux Main Street Passerby No. 1
Eliza Norbury Mary in the Manger
Dan Joffre Caroler No. 2
Aurora Faulkner-Killam Caroler
Melissa Howell Caroler
David Shaw Caroler
Myles Wolfe Caroler
Stephen Holmes UPS Guy
Andrew Hedge City Employee
Cory Monteith Madison's Date