23 of 23The Vampire Diaries
Why It Should Stay: Between Elena recently becoming a vampire and the show's rich mythology, there are still many stories to tell. Plus: The show has been plotted at a breakneck pace and shows no signs of slowing down.
Why It Should Go: The key love triangle between Elena, Damon and Stefan is getting a little tired. Plus: We may be losing one of our favorite characters, Klaus, to the spin-off.
Photo By: Bob Mahoney/The CW