1 of 19 Paul Redmond/WireImage.com
Miss
Amy Poehler looks like she mowed the lawn and glued the grass onto her dress — not quite red carpet style.
2 of 19 Jamie McCarthy/WireImage.com
Miss
We like the idea of Mia Wasikowska's dress, but the length hits at an unflattering spot and the shoulders look too big for her tiny frame.
3 of 19 Mark Sullivan/WireImage.com
Hit
Nikki Reed has the right amount of color paired with her sheer black tights. The belt pulls together the look, we just wish she had pulled together her hair.
4 of 19 Mark Sullivan/WireImage.com
Hit
Leopard prints aren't easy to pull off, but this dress has just the right amount of sass. The natural makeup and pulled-back hair works well with the loud dress.
5 of 19 Jon Furniss/WireImage.com
Miss
It may be winter, but Gillian Anderson could have removed her coat before hitting the red carpet. The all-black look doesn't do much for her pale skin and blonde hair.
6 of 19 Michael Caulfield/WireImage.com
Draw
Tia Carrere has the right idea with her long-sleeved navy dress. The keyhole cutout in the cleavage takes away from the simplicity of the look.
7 of 19 Jim Spellman/WireImage.com
Hit
Bradley Cooper is rocking his tailored suit with just enough color in the shirt peeking out to give it some style.
8 of 19 John Shearer/WireImage.com
Miss
We're not sure what year — or decade? — Heather McComb thinks she's in, but the headband around her forehead paired with the lacy off-the-shoulder top does not say 2011.
9 of 19 John Shearer/WireImage.com
Hit
Michelle Rodriguez doesn't often get girly, but she looks stunning in her jet-black 'one-shoulder gown.
10 of 19 Jim Spellman/WireImage.com
Miss
Alyssa Milano may be hiding her baby bump well, but the outfit looks unfinished and the nude-color top washes her out.
11 of 19 John Shearer/WireImage.com
Hit
Amanda Seyfried is glowing in her fuchsia mini-dress. The teal necklace pairs perfectly with the top of the dress and her smoky makeup brings out the blue in her eyes.
12 of 19 Eric Charbonneau/WireImage.com
Miss
Is Virginia Madsen moonlighting as an extra in a Pepto commercial? Other than the hideous color, the bow and bubble skirt don't help pull this look together.
13 of 19 Duffy-Marie Arnoult/WireImage.com
Miss
Abbie Cornish is going for boy-chic, but fails. The suspenders over the white silk top isn't flattering, nor is the tailoring of the pants.
14 of 19 Todd Williamson/WireImage.com
Miss
Jena Malone looks miserable in her all-white outfit, which includes a frilly dress with matching blazer.
15 of 19 Kevin Winter/Getty Images
Miss
Jennifer Lopez is bringing back plaid, but not in a good way. The shirt is too short and reminiscent of Britney's "Baby One More Time" video.
16 of 19 Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com
Hit
Michelle Trachtenberg is high fashion in her slate gray dress with bunched fabric creating the one shoulder. With so much detail on the dress, the actress played it smart by having a sleek ponytail.
17 of 19 Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com
Miss
Deborah Gibson thinks she's still in the '80s, where all of her hit songs live. At least her look fits right in with the period film's premiere
18 of 19 Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage.com
Draw
Anna Faris looks great in red, but the shoes are too matchy-matchy.
19 of 19 Maury Phillips/WireImage.com
Hit
Kimberly Elise is shining in silver. The dress is tight in the right places and her jewels and handbag match perfectly.